Digital Accessibility: Clarifying Expectations, Tools, and Available Support
As we continue our work to make digital course materials more accessible, we want to clarify some misconceptions that have come to our attention, share guidance on using available accessibility tools, and highlight the support available to faculty.
We recognize that improving digital accessibility can feel overwhelming, particularly when working with complex or specialized course materials or receiving conflicting information from accessibility checkers. Accessibility is not about changing what we teach or lowering academic expectations. It is about ensuring that all students have meaningful access to the content and learning experiences essential to their success. Our goal is to help faculty approach this work with clarity and confidence, and knowing that support and resources are available along the way.
Understanding expectations and the Title II deadline
Under the updated Title II regulations of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), WCAG 2.1 Level AA is now the technical accessibility standard for public institutions. CMU's federal compliance deadline is April 26, 2027. As we work toward this milestone, faculty are expected to actively review their instructional materials and address accessibility barriers.
However, while the expectation is that all course materials will be accessible by the deadline, if any material is identified as still a concern after the deadline, it will not be automatically or immediately removed from a Blackboard course shell – nor will access to that course shell be blocked. We know some materials, such as complex disciplinary-specific content (e.g., formulas, equations, and maps), historical documents, specialized software, or third-party resources, can be challenging to remediate or replace. When that's the case, the Office of Curriculum & Instructional Support (CIS) and our campus partners will work with you to prioritize improvements and identify solutions that preserve instructional value and ensure students have access to course materials.
Accessibility is also more than a future compliance goal. It's an ongoing responsibility, which includes responding promptly whenever a student encounters a barrier. The April 2027 compliance deadline is not the end point for making course materials accessible; it is the starting point for a sustained commitment to making course materials accessible and inclusive for all CMU students.
Our goal is student access, not a Blackboard Ally score
Blackboard Ally is a valuable tool for identifying potential accessibility concerns and providing guidance for improvement. However, an Ally score is not a definitive measure of whether course content is accessible.
A course with a high Ally score may still contain significant accessibility barriers, while a course with a lower score may include warnings that require additional review rather than remediation.
Ally, along with the accessibility checkers built into Microsoft and Adobe products, can help identify potential issues, but these tools cannot replace human judgment informed by awareness and knowledge of accessibility standards and guidelines for implementation. For example:
- A document may pass an automated accessibility check but still contain alternative text that does not adequately describe an important image.
- A video may have captions, but those captions may be inaccurate or incomplete.
- A course may have a high overall score while containing an inaccessible required reading, textbook, or assessment.
The goal is not to achieve a 100% Ally score. The goal is to know what makes a course document accessible and modify documents accordingly to ensure that students can meaningfully access and engage with course content.
What does this mean for faculty?
Faculty are expected to review their instructional materials, identify accessibility barriers, and take appropriate steps to address them. This includes documents, presentations, videos, images, assessments, and other digital learning materials.
As you approach this work, we encourage you to:
- Become knowledgeable about the compliance standards and guidelines. You don't need to be an expert in Title II or WCAG 2.1 Level AA, but you do need a working understanding of how to recognize and address accessibility barriers in your course materials.
- Prioritize meaningful student access. Focus first on courses for the upcoming semester and identify barriers that significantly affect students' ability to access information or participate in learning activities, such as required readings, textbooks, and other essential materials.
- Use accessibility checkers as guides. Review potential issues using Blackboard Ally, Microsoft Accessibility Checker, Adobe Acrobat, and other appropriate tools. No checker is perfect; automated results may require further verification.
- Build accessibility into your regular practices. Creating accessible materials from the beginning is generally easier than remediating them later. Small changes to how you develop documents, presentations, and Blackboard content can make a meaningful difference.
- Seek support when needed. Some accessibility challenges require specialized knowledge or technical assistance. You are not expected to navigate every challenge independently.
Accessibility does not mean eliminating complex content, changing learning objectives, or lowering academic rigor. Whether your course includes maps, equations, data visualizations, multimedia, or other specialized content, the goal is to ensure all students can access the essential information and learning experiences.
Understanding Ally warnings and known issues
We recognize that Blackboard Ally sometimes identifies potential accessibility concerns that may not represent actual barriers. These warnings can be frustrating, particularly when materials have been created using recommended practices or have passed other accessibility checkers.
An Ally warning should prompt review, but it does not automatically mean content needs to be changed. Faculty should use appropriate accessibility tools and professional judgment based on their own knowledge to determine whether a barrier exists. If content is confirmed to be accessible, additional changes solely to improve the Ally score may not be necessary.
To help faculty navigate these situations, please see the "Understanding Ally warnings and known issues" section of our Accessible Course Content Resources page, which includes guidance on verifying potential false positives and determining when additional remediation is needed.
If you encounter a warning that seems incorrect or are unsure how to address an issue, please reach out to us at cis@cmich.edu. We can help determine whether a barrier exists and identify appropriate next steps.
Support and Resources Are Available
You are not expected to do this work alone. CIS, along with our campus partners in the Office of Information Technology (OIT) and the University Library Adobe Digital Lounge, is available to help faculty navigate accessibility expectations and identify practical solutions.
- CIS Accessible Course Content Resources
- Accessibility in Action Self-Paced Training (through Workshops & Orientations in Blackboard)
- CIS Accessibility in Action Tip of the Month
- Check with your college for trainings planned in collaboration with CIS
- Coming in January: Fix it Fridays with CIS Staff
- Watch CIS Events for other upcoming trainings.
Moving forward together
Digital accessibility is an important part of creating inclusive, effective learning environments. It is also work that requires thoughtful decision-making, collaboration, and ongoing attention as we create and update instructional materials.
We appreciate the time and care that faculty are investing in improving access for students. While accessibility tools can help us identify where to focus our efforts, they are only one part of the process. Ultimately, our measure of success is not a number in Backboard Ally, but whether students can access the content and learning opportunities they need and wish them to achieve.
Thank you for your continued commitment to our students and for the work you are doing to make CMU courses more accessible. If you have questions, encounter challenges, or would like assistance reviewing your materials, please don't hesitate to reach out to CIS.